Are Carbs Making You Gain Weight? Here’s What Dietitians Say

Experts explain the relationship between carbohydrate consumption and the impact on your weight.

When it comes to the underlying causes of weight gain, there are countless factors that can play into this. Over the last few decades, carbohydrates (aka carbs), in particular, have cultivated somewhat of a controversial reputation, leaving many to wonder whether or not carbs can make you gain weight. This is why many low-carb diets have been part of the zeitgeist longer than you might have even realized. Although the science behind understanding how carbs affect weight may seem rather modern, low-carb diets have existed since the 1860s. Of course, just because low-carb diets have endured, that doesn’t mean that everyone attempts to keep their carb intake low.

In fact, in a national cross-sectional study that was published by JAMA in 2019 that included 43,996 adults, researchers found that only 9% of the average American daily diet was made up of high-quality carbs from sources like fruits and whole grain foods. On the other hand, a staggering 42% of daily calories appeared to come from low-quality carbs. (Yikes!)

Although this might make you assume that it’s best to immediately and perhaps drastically cut down on the number of carbs you consume, that’s not necessarily true. Frankly, there are a few things that dietitians would like you to know about carbs, including what they are, how they can impact both your health and your weight, as well as how to find just the right balance when it comes to including carbs in your daily diet.

So, are carbs making you gain weight? To find out the answer to this question and also better understand the correlation between carb consumption and weight, we turned to the experts.

What are Carbs?

“Carbohydrates are one of the three macronutrients that provide the body with energy in the form of calories,” Amy Goodson, MS, RD, CSSD, LD, and member of our Medical Expert Board, tells Eat This, Not That! “They are divided into three categories: Fiber, starch, and sugar. Most carbohydrates are broken down into glucose in the digestive process except for fiber—fiber does not digest, and instead, feeds the friendly bacteria in the digestive system.”

Goodson also explains that carbs “provide the body with energy in general and during exercise, as well as help keep blood sugar stable.”

“High-fiber carbohydrates help your gut by providing prebiotic fiber that feeds good bacteria,” says Goodson. “And some carbohydrates also provide soluble fiber, which can help with the maintenance of healthy cholesterol levels.”

A Look At The Types Of Carbs

complex and refined carbs — Shutterstock

You may think of all carbs as the same thing. However, there are two distinct kinds of carbs, which each come from various sources. They also have a very different impact on your body.

Complex Carbs

The first type of carb you should be aware of is complex carbs.

“Complex carbohydrates are made up of sugar molecules in long chains,” explains Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, FAND, award-winning nutrition expert and Wall Street Journal best-selling author of the upcoming Up Your Veggies: Flexitarian Recipes for the Entire Family.”They can be divided into two groups: starch and fiber. Starches include potatoes, rice, and pasta, while fiber includes vegetables like broccoli and cucumbers, and whole grains like brown rice.”

“Simple carbs are the other group in the carbohydrate category that is composed of monosaccharides (single sugars) and disaccharides (double sugars),” says Amidor.

Some examples of complex carbs include fruit, honey, and dairy products like milk.

Refined Carbs

Next, there are refined carbs.

“Refined carbs are more processed and stripped of fiber, and various other nutrients (although some refined carbs are fortified with additional nutrients) and, because of that, are digested more rapidly,” says Lisa Moskovitz, RD, CDN, the CEO of The NY Nutrition Group and author of The Core 3 Healthy Eating Plan, and member of our Medical Expert Board. “Refined carbs include refined flour and added sugar.”

“When you have a whole grain, it has three parts: the bran, germ, and endosperm (the starchy part). A whole grain has all these parts intact,” explains Amidor. “However, a refined grain only includes part of the grain—the starchy part—and not the whole grain.”

“The grains used in these products are stripped of many of the nutrients found in the whole grain,” Amidor adds. “[Because of this], you see the word ‘enriched’ in many refined products, as the food manufacturer added back in many of the nutrients that were lost.”

Examples of refined carbs include white rice, white pasta, and white breads like traditional pizza dough and pastries.

How Carbs Might Make You Gain Weight

“If you consume large portions of any sort of carb (complex or simple) or too many carbs throughout the day—that can lead to overconsumption of calories—and over time, weight gain,” says Amidor.

On top of that, Amidor claims that “choosing refined high calorie, high added sugar, and high saturated fat carbs (like cakes, cookies, pastries) can easily rack up the calories and can lead to weight gain over time.”

This is why—much like any other food—consuming carbohydrates within a healthy context boils down to selecting quality carbs and eating them in moderation as part of a nutritious, well-balanced meal.

Finding A Healthy Balance

Breakfast oatmeal with boiled egg, cherry tomatoes, celery, and microgreens. Healthy balanced food. — Shutterstock

Just like many things in life, when it comes to healthy carb consumption, it’s all about balance and moderation. Although too many carbs can be an issue, the same can be said of not getting enough healthy carbs in your diet.

“While you can survive on a very low-carb diet, you might find that not eating enough carbs can cause poor energy, fatigue, irritability, and increased cravings for carbs or sugar,” says Moskovitz. “Carbs also supply fiber which is an essential nutrient that is imperative for gut health and digestion regulating, as well as fending off degenerative diseases like diabetes and cardiovascular disease.”

To achieve a healthy balance, Moskovitz advises that you “focus on choosing higher fiber carbs that are digested more slowly, and therefore keep you more full for a longer period of time. These include fruits, vegetables, beans, lentils, and whole grains,” she adds. “The more nutritious and fiber-rich carbs you consume, the less likely you are to eat past comfortable fullness.”

Beyond that, Moskovitz recommends “balancing your carbs with plenty of digestion-slowing fats such as nuts, seeds, extra virgin olive oil, and anti-inflammatory organic avocado oil, along with lean protein such as fish, eggs, and poultry.”

“It’s recommended that half your carbs recommended should come from whole grain sources. Veggies and dairy have their own groups, but they do provide carbs along with other nutrients, too,” says Amidor.

“The 2020–2025 Dietary Guidelines for Americans and USDA’s MyPlate provide guidelines for men and women on how many carbs they should be eating,” Amidor adds. Although there’s no “one-size-fits-all” solution for precisely how many carbs men and women should eat, generally speaking, this hinges on your age, current weight, how active you are, your medical history, and other factors.

Your lifestyle, in particular, and the degree of physical activity you engage in each day can greatly impact the amount of carbs you should consume daily.

“Carbohydrate need is based on the amount of exercise you do; move a lot, you need more carbohydrates, move less, you need less carbohydrates,” explains Goodson. “Think about it like a car; the more you drive your car around, the more gas you have to put in it to keep it fueled. [It’s the] same concept.”

Goodson also shares advice on how to best determine the right amount of carbs for fueling your body.

“A good rule of thumb to follow is, if you are active and workout multiple times a week, at meals make 1/3 of your plate whole grain carbohydrate, 1/3 lean protein, and 1/3 vegetables,” says Goodson. “If you are looking to lose weight, tweak your plate to be 1/4 of your plate whole grain carbohydrate, 1/4 lean protein, and 1/2 vegetables; this will help you fill up on more fiber for fewer calories.

“Then it is important to incorporate a high-fiber carbohydrate or fruit with a protein or healthy fat at snacks,” adds Goodson. “Greek yogurt with berries, whole grain crackers with cheese, a 100% whole grain granola bar and beef jerky, an apple with 1–2 tablespoons of peanut butter, etc.,” she suggests.

Sources referenced in this article:

Important Notice: This article was also published at www.eatthis.com by Desirée O where all credits are due. Fact checked by Jordan Powers Willard.

Disclaimer

The watching, interacting, and participation of any kind with anything on this page does not constitute or initiate a doctor-patient relationship with Dr. Farrah™. None of the statements here have been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The products of Dr. Farrah™ are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. The information being provided should only be considered for education and entertainment purposes only. If you feel that anything you see or hear may be of value to you on this page or on any other medium of any kind associated with, showing, or quoting anything relating to Dr. Farrah™ in any way at any time, you are encouraged to and agree to consult with a licensed healthcare professional in your area to discuss it. If you feel that you’re having a healthcare emergency, seek medical attention immediately. The views expressed here are simply either the views and opinions of Dr. Farrah™ or others appearing and are protected under the first amendment.

Dr. Farrah™ is a highly experienced Licensed Medical Doctor certified in evidence-based clinical nutrition, not some enthusiast, formulator, or medium promoting the wild and unrestrained use of nutrition products for health issues without clinical experience and scientific evidence of therapeutic benefit. Dr. Farrah™ has personally and keenly studied everything she recommends, and more importantly, she’s closely observed the reactions and results in a clinical setting countless times over the course of her career involving the treatment of over 150,000 patients.

Dr. Farrah™ promotes evidence-based natural approaches to health, which means integrating her individual scientific and clinical expertise with the best available external clinical evidence from systematic research. By individual clinical expertise, I refer to the proficiency and judgment that individual clinicians acquire through clinical experience and clinical practice.

Dr. Farrah™ does not make any representation or warranties with respect to the accuracy, applicability, fitness, or completeness of any multimedia content provided. Dr. Farrah™ does not warrant the performance, effectiveness, or applicability of any sites listed, linked, or referenced to, in, or by any multimedia content.

To be clear, the multimedia content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health providers with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read or seen in any website, video, image, or media of any kind. Dr. Farrah™ hereby disclaims any and all liability to any party for any direct, indirect, implied, punitive, special, incidental, or other consequential damages arising directly or indirectly from any use of the content, which is provided as is, and without warranties.